The Barren and Hart County property valuation administrators were among several throughout Kentucky cleared of charges in a decision made June 15.
Franklin Circuit Judge Phillip J. Shepard ruled that the PVAs who have been charged with breaking state law by hiring family members had not violated any laws.
The Kentucky Executive Branch Commission had charged Barren County PVA Brad Bailey and Hart County PVA Vicky Reynolds along with nine other PVAs statewide with violating Kentucky Law by hiring family members to work at their PVA office.
The PVAs had argued that they were locally elected and therefore not state officials that would be under the purview o the commission, according to court records.
Judge Shepard agreed with the PVAs contention that their offices did not fall under the jurisdiction of the commission.
There were never any accusation that any of the PVAs relatives were not qualified for there position, nor was it argued they were being paid for work they were not doing, according to court records. The allegation was that simply hiring a relative was a violation of law.
“EBEC is a state agency that regulates the conduct only of state government officers and employees,” according to court records. “Second, the PVAs argue that the hiring of family members (or nepotism) is subject matter that is simply outside the scope of KRS 11 A.”
The statute contains a prohibition against actions to obtain financial gain for family members.
The commission did not charge that any of the PVAs acted in an unethical manner, according to court records.
The 11 PVAs had administrative charges formally filed against them on Sept. 28, 2008.
“If a relative hired by a PVA only payment for services rendered, rather than an unearned gratuity, it is difficult to discern from the plain language of the statute how the hiring of a relative could be construed to violate the KRS 11A.020.
The commission had never previously determined that simply hiring or recommending a relative for a position was a violation of state law, according to court records.
“A troubling aspect of this case is the attempt of the EBEC to change the rules after these PVAs had relied to their detriment on the Commission's prior interpretation of its statutory authority,” according to the decision. “An even greater concern is the Commission's attempt to impose this new interpretation of the law ex post facto, and to penalize PVAs for hiring decisions that were made prior to the time they were put on notice that the Commission had changed its position and concluded the ethics statute now bars nepotism of all sorts.”
Bailey declined to comment about the decision when contacted. Reynolds did not respond by deadline.
Local News
PVAs cleared in court decision
- Local News
-
-
Community remembers
There were a variety of emotions Wednesday night as Glasgow alumni members strolled the halls of the former high school one last time.
-
Fire leaves owner asking, ‘What’s next?’
A fire that destroyed Coffey’s Concrete Products on May 10 left the owners of the 30-year-old business with decisions to make.
-
Lyle will be Memorial Day speaker
Not many veterans can say they didn’t accomplish enough during their time in the United States Marine Corps, but retired Sgt. Maj. Travis Lyle can.
-
Youth theater group brings Grimm production to stage
It’s no longer just Disney and Nickelodeon that make shows by children for children.
-
Monroe County man wins 53rd District
A Monroe County businessman won the Republican primary race Tuesday to represent the Kentucky House of Representatives’ 53rd District.
-
There are many reasons for massive Massie win
Thomas Massie credits his 19-point win over more established opponents in Tuesday’s 4th Congressional District Republican Primary to a coalition of groups and his message of smaller government.
-
Evening Update: Scotties beat ACS for 15th District championship
The Glasgow Scotties baseball team beat the Patriots of Allen County-Scottsville by a score of 3 to 1 to take the 15th District title on Wednesday evening. See more in the Thursday print and e-editions of the Glasgow Daily Times.
-
Evening Update: Lady Scotties win district championship
The Glasgow High School Lady Scotties softball team won the 15th District title Wednesday afternoon by defeating the Allen County-Scottsville Lady Patriots, who were ranked No. 1 in the state, by a score of 1 to 0.
-
Gardner beats Davis
John Gardner was admittedly nervous before the polls closed on Tuesday night.
-
Givens fends off Butler
The Tea Party did not prevail in Barren County or across the 9th Senate District as incumbent Senator David Givens kept his seat against Tea Party challenger and Metcalfe County native Don Butler.
- More Local News Headlines
-
NYPD: Person Implicated in Etan Patz Death
Raw Video: Fire on Nuke-powered Sub in Maine
Illegal Burn Suspected in Nevada Fire
Obama: 'We've Got More Work to Do'
Astrologers Predict Outcome of Presidential Race
Gulf Fishermen Reel From Seafood Troubles
Stuntman Makes Skydive Without Parachute in UK
FAMU Bandmates: Victim Volunteered to Be Hazed
Raw Video: Bride Who Faked Cancer Released
Raw Video: Tornado Appears During Wedding
Raw Video: Passed Out Man Robbed
Inquiry Hears Wider Secret Service Misbehavior
HP to Cut 27,000 Jobs, Save Up to $3.5B
